Answers
- The "Adult Literacy in America" study initiated
by Congress in 1988 and reported upon in1993 was a $14 million
5-year study by the National Assessment Governing Board in conjunction
with the National Center for Educational Statistics "based
upon lengthy interviews with 26,000 adults [from 16 to 65 years
old] in a dozen states." "They used careful demographic
sampling with accurate proportions of males and females, all
ethnic and racial groups, and balanced for geographic location
(urban, inner city, rural, etc.)." They used an innovative
and objective way to measure functional literacy, the
ability to use reading skill to perform the normal activities
of modern life. The Educational Testing Service ensured that
all interviewees were also monitored by outside testers. "Strict
guidelines were set up for scoring responses, and data analysis
was done by trained specialists at a central location. All test
items were secured, and no school had access to any of them or
even samples of them." They reported in 1993 that 92 million
Americans, over 47 % of adults, "read and write so poorly
that it is difficult for them to hold an above-poverty-level-wage
job."
Source: (1) Mary Jordan, writer for The Washington
Post, "Nearly Half of Adults in America Lack Necessary
Skills, Study Says," The Salt Lake Tribune, September
9, 1993, p. A1, col. 2-3. (2) Diane McGuinness, Ph.D., Why
Our Children Can't Read (New York: Simon & Schuster,
1997), pp. 7-10. (3) http://nces.ed.gov/pubs93/93275.pdf, a free,
downloadable government report.
- The American Management Association, a not-for-profit provider
of management training based in New York, reported that the overall
failure rate of job applicants to meet the minimum job requirement
for the job they sought for the 1990s (until 1996, the year of
the report) was 36.3%.
Source: Associated Press, "Job Seekers Can't
Read Or Do Math," The Salt Lake Tribune, May 8, 1996,
p. B12, col. 4-5.
- The Literacy in the Labor Force report proved that
more than 40% of employees in U.S. businesses are functionally
illiterate. Source: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs99/1999479.pdf.
- Jonathan Kozol's book, Illiterate America, updated
with more recent newspaper articles show that illiteracy cost
the average taxpayer at least $3700 each year. This is
made up of at least $100 billion for government programs providing
services for illiterates and at least $200 billion for the higher
consumer costs as a result of illiterates in the workplace each
year, giving a total of at least $300 billion each year.
At least 30% of the $450 billion annual cost of crime in the
U.S. (which does not include the cost of running prisons, jails,
and the probation and parole system, which would probably add
another $40 billion) can be directly attributed to illiteracy,
adding another $135 billion. A total of $435 ($300 billion plus
$135 billion) divided by 117.6 million persons in the labor market
in December 1990, the latest readily available figure, results
in at least $3700 per taxpayer each year.
Source: (1) Jonathan Kozol, Illiterate America
(Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor Press/Doubleday, 1985), various places
throughout the book, as summarized on the back jacket cover (2)
The Washington Post, "Illiteracy 'Crisis' Scares
U.S. Executives," Salt Lake Tribune, October 8, 1995,
p. F8, col. 1-2 (3) Anne C. Lewis, special to The Baltimore
Sun, "Press Misses Scary Story In Failing to Cover Literacy
Adequately," The Salt Lake Tribune, September 14,
1989, p. A17, col. 2-3 (4) Associated Press, "U.S. Crime's
Price Tag Runs $450 Billion a Year," The Salt Lake Tribune,
April 23, 1996, p. A7.
- The Pew Research Center poll showed that 88% of those
polled considered education "very important." A 1993
magazine poll showed that "63% of Americans rate the quality
of public education as poor or fair." A recent newspaper
article said that parents seemed "desperate," sometimes
standing in line all night to get their children enrolled in
an elementary school that they thought would be better.
Source: (1) Pew Research Center poll, October 28-31, 1998
(2) Mark Clements, "What's Wrong With Our Schools,"
Parade Magazine, May 16, 1993, p. 4 (3) Richard Whitmire,
for Gannett News Service, "Parents in 90s Desperate About
Quality Education," The Salt Lake Tribune, April
7, 1996, p. A10, col. 1-2.
- The U.S. high school students ranked 19th in international
science and math competition with 20 other industrial nations,
exceeding only Cyprus and South Africa. Asian nations were not
included in the competition; if Asian nations such as Japan,
Korea, and Taiwan had been included, the U.S. ranking would undoubtedly
have been worse than it was.
Source: Prime-time major network news coverage on February
25, 1998.
- U.S. Department of Education figures show that "75%
of prison inmates and 85% of juveniles in correctional facilities
are functionally illiterate." This compares to 47% of
all adults in the U.S. who are functionally illiterate, as shown
in question 1.
Source: Taylor Syphus, "He's Learning to Read, "
The Salt Lake Tribune, December 16, 1995, pp.E1 and E10.
- Albert Shanker stated, "Ninety-five percent of
the kids who go to college in the United States would not be
admitted to college anywhere else in the world."
Source: Carol Innerst, "Schools 'Really Bad' Says
AFT Leader," The Washington Times, July 6, 1990 as
quoted in Dr. Bill Bennett's book The Index of Leading Cultural
Indicators (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1994), p. 89,
an excellent source for educational and other measures of America's
social problems.
- The U.S. ranked 49th among 158 U.N. nations in 1983.
More recent direct comparisons are not readily available, but
a more recent comparison is available by comparing the above
stated 47% illiteracy rate (or a 53% literacy rate) with the
international literacy rate of 72%. It may well be that the evaluation
criteria used in the international study was less rigorous that
the U.S. study, but it should be noted that many other nations
do not have mandatory elementary school education as does the
U.S., and a much smaller percentage of the population in many
nations have enough education to achieve literacy. Furthermore,
many nations do not try to ensure that every student can graduate
from elementary school, as the U.S. does. As a result, the "best
and brightest" in many nations receive an education; the
others "flunk out."
Source: (1) Jonathan Kozol's book, Illiterate America,
pp. 5 and 226, which quotes The Washington Post and Foundation
News articles mentioned in the question on the previous page
(2) "Numbers," Time magazine, July 26, 1999,
p. 17.
- Less than 4% of adult illiterates enroll in any of the government
and private literacy programs. Only 15% of adult illiterates
who enroll in literacy programs complete the eighth grade. The
percentage of all adult illiterates who achieve eighth grade
reading ability is about 0.04 times 0.15 or 0.6%.
Source: (1) Kozol's book Illiterate America,
p. 5 (2) Carmen Hunter's and David Harman's book Adult Literacy
in the United States (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company,
1985), p. 165.
- It has been pointed out that two million students
drop out of school or graduate every year who cannot even read
whatever diploma they may receive, and less than one percent
of them ever become proficient readers after leaving school,
as question 9 shows.
Source: Rick Gladstone, Associated Press writer, "Reading
Writing on the Wall? America May Face Literacy Crisis,"
The Salt Lake Tribune, February 21, 1988, p. F4, col.
1.
- Frank Laubach stated in his books that students of 95% of
the languages in which he taught became fluent readers in less
than three months. Source: (1) Frank C. Laubach,
Forty Years With the Silent Billion, pp. 36 and 478. (2)
Sanford S. Silverman, Spelling for the 21st Century, p.
v.
- It takes most of our students who learn to read well enough
to become functionally literate two to four years!
Source: Rudolph Flesch, Why Johnny Can't Read,
pp. 76-77.
- All of the items were included in Ms. Schoutten's report.
Source: Fredreka Schouten, for Gannett News Service, "
'At Risk' Report 20 Years Later," The Salt Lake Tribune,
April 20, 2003, p. A13.
- The gap in the academic achievement levels of the U.S. and better
performing nations knocked $2.3 trillion off the U.S. GDP in 2008 (about 16% of 2008 GDP).
Stated more simply: Functional illiteracy reduced the U.S. GDP about $2.3
trillion in 2008. Source: The Greensboro, North Carolina Oct. 10, 2009
Rhinotimes.com (http://greensboro.rhinotimes.com/Articles-i-2009-10-01-200322.112113_School)